A couple of weeks ago, I happened to be teaching fractions (addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, simplification, with variables) to pre-service teachers at exactly the same time as I was learning about teaching fractions and proportional reasoning in a unit I'm taking in my teaching qualification. I spent a week with my two brains confused, but by the end of it realised how ordinary my teaching of fractions is. One of the big problems I came to realise was my wording of concepts, methods, etc. I happened to be explaining to a student why I always say to multiply fractions by something over something when trying to add fractions.
This was the actual example in the figure. "Why are you doing this x over x multiplication?" was the question. I responded by asking what x/x was and 3/3, to which the student thankfully replied "one", and then I went on with something about how multiplying by x/x or 3/3 is fine because I'm just multiplying by one so I'm not changing anything... just the appearance of the fraction, so that we can have them all looking the same. In essence, I guess that's ok, but I think I could say more to make it more clear why or where this comes from. This got me thinking, again, about something that is a particular interest of mine: the issue of how we word our explanations.
I was just listening again to one of the lecture videos for my teaching qualification unit on mathematics curriculum and it got me thinking about a new way to talk about this whole fraction addition thing. Essentially, we are undoing a simplification. Imagine that the fractions given in the question were all originally of the same denominator, but some evil mathematics lecturer came along and simplified them all to their individual simplest form. Our job is to undo that simplification and write them back in their original forms, with a common denominator.
It's nothing amazing, I just wanted to write it down somewhere! I'm interested in how other people (both maths teachers/lecturers and teachers of maths teachers) go about explaining this...

I teach 'building up fractions' (for example, by dividing each of part of the whole into smaller pieces) first. It then seems somewhat easier for me to make the argument about reducing/simplifying to an equivalent form.
ReplyDeleteThe best resource I've found so far is James Tanton's pamphlet on why fractions are hard to understand: http://www.jamestanton.com/?p=1461 . It transformed my teaching. I won't say I've got it right now, but it is definitely better!
Cool - thanks Amie!
Delete