Most of the time in mathematics when we hear "online" and "assessment" we're thinking or talking about multichoice quizzes in a learning management system, or perhaps the more mathematically sophisticated options offered by WeBWorK or Numbas. That's all great, but it's not what I'm talking about here. This post is about:
- students submitting handwritten or typeset work online
- academics grading and providing feedback on that work, again, online, and
- returning graded student work to them via online means.
Now in theory, this is great. Online submission is trackable and proof of submission is fairly easy. Plagiarism detection is significantly automated through, for example, turnitin. Typed feedback and rubric-based grading is also often built into these systems. But what about problem/solution style quantitative disciplines like mathematics, physics and engineering? My colleagues and I found great difficulty in adhering to this new system given that we wanted students to submit worked solutions to mathematical problems (often entirely symbolic/graphical representation), to handwrite feedback to them (again in symbolic/graphical representations), and to get this feedback to them as quickly and seamlessly as possible.
There are certainly issues here, but not insurmountable ones:
- Handwritten work can fairly easily be scanned to PDF through photocopiers or "scanned" via smartphones. Online submission is then feasible. ADDED PROBLEMS: File formats, unfamiliarity with technology.
- Handwritten feedback can be provided by printing out PDFs or by using PDF annotators on smart devices/tablets. ADDED PROBLEMS: Printing costs $$$ and is environmentally troublesome. Tablets/devices are costly and generally speaking not owned by all academics. The ability to use the PDF annotators requires training.
- Feedback can be returned to students by re-scanning the printed copies or transferring annotated files back to the students. ADDED PROBLEMS: Scanning takes time ($$$). Transfer of files is not seamless and again takes time ($$$).
One of the most successful ways to get over most of these issues, that I've found, has been to use Microsoft's OneNote with its ClassNotebook add in. At its heart, OneNote is essentially freeform note taking taking software. It allows both text based and inking input (ie using a pen on a tablet), as well as the capability to import the contents of a file (say a PDF) into a note space. In the maths classroom, this is great because these three things allow students to input their mathematics in authentic ways: handwritten straight onto the screen, typed (just like in MS Word docs), or handwritten and scanned to a PDF and imported to the notebook. So it seems that one side of the story (the student) is catered for.
But what about the academic and the feedback process? Well that's where ClassNotebook comes in. The addin is in some sense a way to provide learning management system-like capabilities from within the OneNote notebooks you might want to create, as well as the sharing of notebook spaces. There's lots of things that can be done here including simply co-authoring notes, communicating synchronously and asynchronously, locking spaces, and so on. But back to the issue of online assessment in maths, here's what I did.
First, I was able to share a OneNote notebook with all of my students so that they could see the same notebook as me. This can either be done manually, or if your LMS is setup appropriately, by linking to that LMS and the contained classlist. I had notes and so forth in the notebook that I shared with the students. They could see these note pages, make copies of them and then edit them as much as they liked (I retained a clean copy). Students each had their own personal spaces in the notebook that only they and I could see. We could interact through these as well. I also had my own hidden space where I could keep notes etc.
Now for the key part: I could share an assessment item handout with my students and automatically set up a space where each student would attempt the assessment. When the due date and time came around, I could grab each of these (electronically speaking) and keep what amounts to a timestamped copy of their work, which I would then edit, mark, annotate etc. I could do this by typing, or because I have a tablet by inking straight onto the work itself. If I wanted to I could even make audio and video annotations if that made it easier to explain something. When I was ready, I could return a copy of this to each individual student's workspace with a couple of mouse clicks.
Fantastic! But this is just one idea. I'm really interested to know what other people are doing in the electronic/online assessment space. Let me know!
No comments:
Post a Comment